Are non-producing ASX lithium companies now way over-priced?

The fastest-growing ASX lithium share today has not yet dug a gram out of the ground.

| More on:

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Key points
  • Wilsons equity strategist Rob Crookston prefers to invest in lithium companies already producing the commodity 
  • Crookston says "there is more exuberance in the non-producers, and valuations may have overshot fair value" 
  • Allkem and Pilbara Minerals are two ASX lithium shares backed by the Wilsons team 

One of the top five best-performing ASX shares of 2022 is a lithium explorer yet to produce a single gram of the commodity.

But this isn't unusual. The share market is forward-looking and investors tend to make decisions based on the future prospects of younger companies in hot sectors like lithium mining.

A male investor sits at his desk looking at his laptop screen holding his hand to his chin pondering whether to buy Macquarie shares

Image source: Getty Images

What's the hottest lithium stock on the market today?

For now, investors are just loving Core Lithium Ltd (ASX: CXO). Its share price is up around 130% in the year to date. Investors are clearly excited about its future.

Like all ASX lithium shares, Core Lithium is benefiting from a record lithium carbonate price. It may not be producing any as yet, but it's reportedly only months off first production at its Finniss Lithium Project in the Northern Territory.

For now, Wilsons equity strategist Rob Crookston is bullish on lithium shares but sceptical about non-producers.

Crookston writes on Livewire:

We prefer lithium miners, like Allkem Ltd (ASX: AKE), who are currently producing lithium. We are more sceptical about the small-cap non-producers. We believe there is more exuberance in the non-producers, and valuations may have overshot fair value.

While Crookston does not refer to any specific non-producers, you can understand his logic, right?

The price of lithium carbonate hit a new record high this month at US$77,767.49 per tonne. It just keeps on setting new benchmarks as demand for electric vehicles around the world continues to surge.

So, of course, it makes sense that companies who are already getting lithium out of the ground and taking it to market right now are best placed to capitalise on the record commodity price.

Wilsons team likes Allkem best

Allkem is the Wilsons team's preferred ASX lithium share. Crookston explains:

AKE is one of the world's top 5 lithium producers, with operations in brine, spodumene, and hydroxide. Business operations are spread across Argentina, Australia, Canada and Japan.

The company has deep brine and hard rock lithium resources and a depth of experience in these fields. AKE brine production is low cost relative to the Western Australia spodumene (hard rock) mines.

We believe consolidation is likely in the pipeline for AKE, one of the biggest players in South America's 'Lithium Triangle'. The company could acquire smaller explorers to increase its capacity.

Allkem shares closed on Friday at $14.07, down 2.76% for the day and up 26% in 2022.

What other ASX lithium share does Wilsons back?

Pilbara Minerals Ltd (ASX: PLS) is another lithium favourite of the Wilsons team.

Crookston says:

[Pilbara is a] pureplay lithium miner. Owns 100% of the Pilgangoora hard-rock lithium mine in Western Australia, as well as 18% of a downstream joint venture with POSCO with an option to increase to 30%.

Spodumene production is expected to increase to ~1mt by FY28, up from 360kt in FY22.

While PLS screens attractively on near-term valuation multiples, the company appears to offer less valuation appeal over the medium-term.

Pilbara Minerals shares ended Friday's session at $4.87 apiece, down 4.7% for the day and up 38% in 2022.

Motley Fool contributor Bronwyn Allen has positions in Allkem Limited. The Motley Fool Australia's parent company Motley Fool Holdings Inc. has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool Australia has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. This article contains general investment advice only (under AFSL 400691). Authorised by Scott Phillips.

More on Resources Shares

Two miners standing together with a smile on their faces.
Resources Shares

These are the best ASX 200 mining shares to buy in March: Morgans

These mining shares are on Morgans' best ideas list in March.

Read more »

A man in his 30s holds his laptop and operates it with his other hand as he has a look of pleasant surprise on his face as though he is learning something new or finding hidden value in something on the screen.
Resources Shares

Rio Tinto share price dips despite copper mega-mine milestone

Rio Tinto owns 66% of what will soon become the world's fourth-largest copper mine.

Read more »

Miner looking at his notes.
ESG

'Not sure if that's the way we should go': Why BHP shares are making news today

BHP is trialling renewable diesel made from Hydrotreated Vegetable Oil (HVO) at its Western Australian Yandi iron ore mine.

Read more »

A young woman sits at her desk in deep contemplation with her hand to her chin while seriously considering information she is reading on her laptop
Resources Shares

Are Fortescue shares back on the menu amid job cuts?

Can cost reductions be the key to driving Fortescue ahead?

Read more »

A man wearing a hard hat and high visibility vest looks out over a vast plain where heavy mining equipment can be seen in the background.
Resources Shares

Could buying Fortescue shares at under $22 make me rich?

The iron ore miner Fortescue has seen volatility. Is it time to buy?

Read more »

Australian Strategic Materials employee wearing a hard hat at a mine looks into the distance as he checks a folder.
Resources Shares

Sayona Mining share price dumps 6% amid lithium lows

Lithium prices have fallen to their lowest level in more than a year.

Read more »

Rede arrow on a stock market chart going down.
Resources Shares

Why are ASX 200 lithium shares falling so hard today?

The lithium carbonate price has fallen to its lowest level in more than a year.

Read more »

A young man sits at his desk with a laptop and documents with a gas heater visible behind him as though he is considering the information in front of him. about the BHP share price
Resources Shares

Why is the BHP share price taking a flogging on Friday?

The commodity growth engine may not be firing on all cylinders.

Read more »